With 185 candidates in fray for Nizamabad EC decides to use jumbo EVMs

vvpatHyderabad, Apr 01: Contrary to reports that ballot papers will be used at the Nizamabad Lok Sabha constituency in Telangana, the Election Commission of India has decided to go ahead with jumbo Electronic Voting Machines.

The constituency is witnessing a record fight, with 185 candidates filing their nominations. The EC has directed the state authorities to procure a M-3 sized EVM for polling instead of ballot papers. The EC directed the Electronic Corporation of India Limited to supply 26,820 ballot units, 22,420 control units and 2,600 VVPATs of M3 make for the elections.

Read more 

With 185 candidates in fray for Nizamabad LS seat, EC shuns EVMs

Hyderabad, Mar 29: Electronic Voting Machines will not be used for the first time in the elections to be held at Telangana’s Nizamabad Lok Sabha seat. The constituency polls on April 11.

The decision not to use the EVM was taken owing to the large number of candidates contesting from this seat. The constituency is currently represented by K Kavitha, daughter of Telangana Chief Minister, K Chandrashekhar Rao.

Read more

Uttarakhand HC stays ECI’s EVM challenge, calls it unconstitutional

Pic: The Hindu

The Uttarakhand High Court has stayed the EVM challenge organised by the Election Commission of India. The court observed that the ECI does not have the authority to undertake such an exercise. The court held that such an exercise is unconstitutional in nature. Hence the hackathon to be conducted tomorrow cannot be held the court said while issuing the stay order. The court also directed the ECI to conduct a full bench meeting today itself. The court said that following the meeting the ECI must inform it about the plans of conducting the EVM hackathon.

Read more

SC notice to Union govt on EVM use without paper trail

Pic: The Hindu

The Supreme Court on Thursday issued notices to the Union government among others on a petition challenging the use of EVMs without a paper trail.

Read more

At 1.2 per cent, Goa used the NOTA option most

It was Goa that used the None of the Above button on the EVM machine the most. 1.2 per cent of the voters used the option to say that they did not want any of the candidates to win the elections.

Read more

EVM- Is there accountability

vvpatAccountability of the vote that a citizen polls became a matter of debate in the 2009 elections. This time too that is likely to be an issue since the much needed voter verified paper audit trail or the VVPAT will not be seen in a majority of the constituencies. Despite a Supreme Court ruling in a ruling given last year had directed the Election Commission of India to introduce VVPAT for the 2014 elections. It also observed that VVPAT is indispensable for free and fair elections.

Continue reading “EVM- Is there accountability”

EVM- is fraud at play?

Pic: The Hindu
Pic: The Hindu

With the elections nearing, the debate regarding the veracity of an Electronic Voting Machine has begun once again. The Save Indian Democracy which had exposed the fraud that was being committed through an EVM says that despite so much that has been exposed the Election Commission of India has gone ahead buying an additional 2 lakh such machines.

Satya Dosapati of the Save Indian Democracy tells rediff.com that it is alarming that the ECI is buying 2 lakh additional machines. Moreover the combining of the state and parliamentary elections and the use of such machines will only create an environment for fraud.

Continue reading “EVM- is fraud at play?”

What the law ministry isn’t telling us

There has been a long standing demand to bar criminals from contesting the elections. Union Law Minister, Veerappa Moily pointed out that at the moment there is a consensus on the issue and we would have to discuss the matter further before making the recommendations to the Union Government.

Moily was positive that these reforms would come through and exercise to debar chargesheeted candidates from contesting elections has had the consensus during the regional consulations on electoral reforms. Let us see how things would shape up during the national consultation. But till date the response has been very good and it looks positive.

However what the Law Minister is not telling us is that this issue was not all that was discussed during the regional consultations. In fact some persons who have attended a majority of these meetings told us that it had turned out to be more of a grievance redressal cell for the MLAs and MPs.

Anil Bairwal, coordinator of the Association of Democratic Reforms who has participated in most of these meetings points out that the biggest drawback was this was not a public participation and was done by invitation. This is a matter that concerns our people since it is a question about their leaders and hence we felt that the discussions should have involved the public as well.

About the optimism of the Law Minister, well I would say that such excercises have been conducted in the past. Sonia Gandhi herself had said that criminal candidates should be barred from contesting the elections. However election after election the Congress continued to float candidates with a criminal background. Although I do not want to sound too cynical and really hope something comes out of these deliberations, I would want to add that the political will is lacking. A few consultations is not sufficient to change the scenario. We may discuss a lot of things and even give our recommendations, but then see what is happening with the Lok Pal bill. A lot of things can be shot down at the last moment. Hence I say that a political will is very important in such issues.

To Moily’s credit, he has taken the lead and is doing the best he can. From what all of us guage of this exercise, we realise that there is no political will, the will to effect reforms. In fact Moily when he was the Chairman of the Administrative Reforms Commission, he had made similar proposals regarding the same issue. Did anything come out? No. However let us give him due credit, he is trying his best.

This issue is a serious one and just issuing mere statements will not do. There have been many such debates in the past as well, but it always gets shot down at the last moment. We are just keeping our fingers crossed.

Moily does speak of overwhelming support, but from what we saw at the meeting, we did not find anything of this sort. First and foremost these were not public consultations and were by invitation. The sessions comprised MLAs and Chief Ministers and also members of the election commission.

During the meetings we did notice one thing that slowly the issue pertaining to chargesheeted MLAs was discussed very less. The leaders used it as a platform to redress their grievances. The biggest grievance was that the election commission of India had become very strict and the candidates during the elections were not allowed to put up posters. Further they spent a lot of time cribbing about not having a free hand during the elections. They complained about the problems in the voter’s list and how the ECI had become exceptionally strict during the elections. Hence the long and short of all these discussions was that hardly 10 per cent of the time was spent on debating and discussing the real issue.

What needs to be done?

Section 125A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, should be amended to provide for more stringent punishment for concealing or providing wrong information on Form 26 of Conduct of Election Rules, 1961 to minimum two years imprisonment and removing the alternative punishment of assessing a fine upon the candidate

The information submitted in the affidavits by the candidates should be certified by Political Parties

The information given in the affidavits of the candidates on criminal charges, assets etc. should be verified by an independent central authority in a time bound manner

Any person against whom a charge has been framed by a court of law, in a criminal case for which the punishment is imprisonment of two years or more, should not be allowed to contest elections, and any political party that gives a ticket to such an individual should be ―deregistered and derecognized forthwith.

EVMs should have an option or a button for ―None-of-the-above.

Political parties should be required to maintain proper accounts and these accounts should be available for public scrutiny

The Election Commission has recently got the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) to draw up guidelines concerning the formats, frequency, scrutiny, etc. of the accounts to be maintained by political parties. These guidelines should be made mandatory, and any failure to comply with these should lead to automatic de-registration of the party

There should be a ceiling on the expenditure that a candidate can incur during the election. This ceiling should be fixed, and revised periodically, by the Election Commission of India, without the need of any reference or recommendation to the government.

The government should empower the Election Commission to take whatever steps necessary to ensure (a) accurate, updated electoral rolls, (b) that every citizen to be able to (i) register her/his vote at any place of his choosing and any time of the year, and (ii) be able to cast one‘s voter wherever one happens to be on the date of polling

Common electoral rolls should be used for all elections. The needs of the electoral rolls to be used for parliamentary and state assembly elections on the one hand, and those for local bodies and panchayats on the other, should be harmonized; and necessary legislation, in case it is needed, should be done immediately

If any independent candidate fails to win five percent of the vote or more, he should be debarred from contesting as an independent for the same office for six years

An independent candidate who loses election three times consecutively for the same office as an independent should be permanently debarred from contesting election to that office

A person should not be allowed to contest from more than one constituency at a time

There should be a provision for filing election petitions even against candidates who have lost the election, in instances where they have indulged in corrupt practices during the election

A new Section 126-A should be introduced in the Representation of the People Act, 1951, prohibiting conducting of exit polls and publishing results in any manner, during the period starting from 48 hours before the close of poll in an election, with the prohibition lasting till the close of poll in the last phase in case of a multi-phased election. This amendment should cover opinion polls also, and that Section-126 (1)(b) should be made applicable to print media also.

There should be a limit on the expenditure that can be incurred in the Election to a Legislative Council, as in the case of Lok Sabha and State Assembly elections, and the candidates should also be required to submit the account of election expenses just as candidates for Lok Sabha and State Assembly election.

Use of religion, caste, community, tribe, and any other form of group identity for electoral gain or for gathering political support should not be allowed and the Representation of the People Act, 1951,be suitably amended to give the Election Commission powers to take deterrent actions against those candidates and political parties who resort to it, such actions should include, but not limited to, disqualifying candidates from contesting elections and de-registering the offending political parties. Political parties should also not be allowed to use overtly religious, caste,

Legislative Councils in all states be abolished

Whips should be issued only when the existence of the government is at stake and not otherwise

There should be limit prescribed for the amount of donation that a political party can accept from an individual, company, organization, or any entity (Para 9.3).

Political parties should maintain should be required to maintain proper accounts in predetermined account heads

Accounts of political parties should be audited by auditors recommended and approved by the Comptroller and Auditor General of India.

The current scenario:

As on today, there are 153 MPs in our parliament who have a criminal record. Despite all the talk about reforms the irony is that the number of candidates with a criminal background has gone up from 128 to 153 during the 2009 polls. In addition to this 15 MPs in Parliament have one murder charge against them.

In this list, the BJP has 43 and the Congress has 41 such candidates. Ironically in this list of 153, 74 MPs have very serious criminal charges against them. These candidates were given tickets despite them declaring in their affidavits their pending criminal charges.